rise header

March 25, 2025

Jaci white background

From the Desk of

Jaci A. Thiede ¦ Partner

The Unconventional Hire – Worth the Risk? 

A little over a month ago, I received a text from a former colleague that began with, “Thank you for taking a chance on me 14 years ago; doing so helped change the trajectory of my career.” He then shared the news that he had been named the Chief Philanthropy Officer of a major university in Australia. I love seeing people I care about grow and succeed, so this would be a happy story, even without an additional twist. However, there is one, and I’ve been reflecting on it ever since I received his message.

The twist is that he was a completely “non-traditional” candidate for a major gifts position when we hired him. He had no direct professional fundraising or even sales experience. However, he had: 1) consistently expressed his desire to enter the development profession; 2) demonstrated a deep belief in and passion for the mission of the organization through many years of service in a completely unrelated department; and 3) a lengthy history of volunteer service with various non-profit organizations.

He also had skills that truly matter in major gift work: emotional intelligence, genuine curiosity about people, excellent listening skills, the ability to adapt and learn quickly, and the rare ability to connect deeply with people, no matter their background. All those qualities and characteristics were enough for us to take a calculated risk and hire him. The risk was well worth it.

I share this story because, in the competitive world of nonprofit fundraising, conventional wisdom often leads us—me included—to seek candidates with proven track records in closing major gifts. We look for candidates who can hit the ground running, who speak our fundraising language, and who know exactly how to navigate the delicate dance of donor cultivation, solicitation, and stewardship. All that makes good strategic sense.

COVID has changed the hiring landscape for major gift officers over the past five years. It remains very much a “seller’s market” when it comes to recruiting and retaining top-notch major gift officers. No doubt hiring experienced fundraisers who can successfully navigate the development landscape holds tremendous value. However, in today’s marketplace, it’s crucial to remember that while the technical knowledge of fundraising can be learned, the intrinsic qualities that make someone truly exceptional at building meaningful donor relationships are much harder to teach.

I encourage anyone seeking to recruit major gift talent to remain open to candidates who offer diverse gifts, talents, and experiences. Of course, you should still pursue experienced major gift officers, but also stay receptive to considering unconventional candidates if they demonstrate:

  • A genuine connection to your mission and the communities you serve.
  • Very strong interpersonal skills and emotional intelligence.
  • The ability to listen deeply and respond/follow up thoughtfully.
  • Curiosity, adaptability, and a commitment to continuous learning.
  • A track record of building lasting relationships in their previous work.

Major gift work requires patience, diligence, creativity, and passion. So does hiring someone to do such important work. Stay open to possibilities and candidates who don’t seem like layups…they may just turn out to be slam dunks!

Happy March Madness!

Independent Schools & Philanthropic Funds Data

We’ve got new data in from some Independent School Associations. Georgia Independent School Association is up next. Let’s look at what participating schools raised in philanthropic funds in this regional association for data entry year 2024-2025. 

School Count   42 

Advancement Median Funds Received for ’24 $1,708,687
Median Number of Donors 741
  
Median Percent Participation by
Constituency & Hard Credit Funds Received
 
Median % Participation by Parents/Guardians of Current Students 61.6%  $526,445
Median % Participation by Alumni/ae  7.3%    $43,317
Median % Participation by Grandparents of Current Students 10.8%  $181,763
Median % Participation by Parents & Grandparents of Alumni/ae  6.3%   $202,722
Median % Participation by Employees 66.3%   $37,975
Trustees 
Median Number of Trustees 16
Median Hard Credit Funds Received by Trustees $81,283
Median Soft Credit Funds Received by Trustees $109,127
  
Funds Received by Purpose (’24) 
Median Funds Received for Current Operations: Unrestricted $740,209
Median Funds Received for Current Operations: Restricted  $241,732
Median Funds Received for Endowment $206,306
Median Funds Received for Other Capital Purposes $686,897
Median Funds Received for Irrevocable Deferred Gifts at Face Value           $0

Data from NAIS Facts at a Glance. 

Donors Stepped Up at Year’s End

According to the latest GivingPulse survey, monetary gifts in the fourth quarter of 2024 increased by 21% compared to the third quarter. giving behaviors—including monetary and nonmonetary donations—and sentiments. The fourth quarter data noted that 13% of people were asked to give and responded by doing so. This share is higher than it was in the third quarter of 2024 but the same as the fourth quarter of 2023.

This indicates that trust in nonprofits was strong among those surveyed by GivingTuesday. The survey presented results categorized by community type. Trust was highest in the “middle suburbs,” where 95% expressed their confidence in nonprofits. Although still significant, fewer respondents- 85%- from the “aging farmlands and evangelical hubs” stated they trust nonprofits. COP, 3-28 

Rethinking Big Gifts 5 Years After the Pandemic

Five years ago, in the early days of Covid-19’s arrival, it would have been impossible to predict how the era of pandemic lockdowns would ultimately upend the status quo of fundraising. The pandemic reshaped how donor relationships are forged and major gifts are won. Many of these changes were overdue, say experienced leaders, and they could even be positive in the long run.

Here are some key ways to attract major gifts in a post-pandemic world.

Take a Hybrid Approach to Donor Meetings
Video calls have become the default in donor outreach. However, there are tradeoffs. A hybrid approach is arranging an in-person visit after getting to know a prospect online or to keep the relationship going.

Throw Mission-Aligned Events
Black-tie galas are out. These days, your wealthiest supporters are more likely to want to see your group in action, which can be done in ways that are more innovative and mission-focused than hosting an exclusive party.

Connect with Donors’ Values
Many wealthy philanthropists who became richer during the pandemic are eager to do more to tackle systemic inequities. Trust-based philanthropy is gaining importance, and unrestricted donations have risen among philanthropists inspired by MacKenzie Scott’s approach of no-strings-attached giving.

Use Multiyear Campaigns to Inspire New and Existing Supporters
The multiyear campaign attracted new supporters and inspired existing donors to augment their giving, resulting in an increase in gifts over the $25,000 threshold

Enhance Stewardship With AI
Generative AI has become an indispensable tool for streamlining operations at nonprofits since ChatGPT hit the market in 2022. Fundraisers can judiciously use the new technology while still satisfying donors’ needs for authenticity and personal connection, the experts say. The technology also enables staff to increase the number of donors they can cultivate. COP, 3-11

We Know Independent Schools
For more than 35 years, Alexander Haas has been a fixture in the nonprofit community. We are honored to have worked with so many remarkable independent schools, both secular and non-secular, across the country that help mold today’s adolescents into tomorrow’s leaders. Take a look at our list of independent school clients, past and present.

A Fresh Approach to Fundraising
Our services aren’t cookie cutter. We don’t operate with a boilerplate, merely changing names and locations. We craft each and every service we provide to match your organization’s unique needs, wants and abilities. We work hard and expect you to do the same. Together we can help you transform your institution, your fundraising, and the community you serve.

Whether your need is in Capital Campaign, Annual Fund Campaign, Major Gifts, Leadership Annual Giving, Planned Giving or all of the above, we take a fresh approach to nonprofit fundraising.